This week we are asked to estimate
costs, duration and effort associated with our particular projects and think
about the same estimations for future hypothetical projects. I find this
project particularly daunting and intimidating. The challenge of this week’s
application is that I have no previous knowledge to draw upon. If I were employed
as an instructional designer, I would have to do a lot of research in order to
have an accurate picture of the resources that are required to produce a
quality instructional design project. To research for this project and gather
some background knowledge to build upon, I reviewed three online resources.
The first
online resource was titled Estimating Time and
Resources in Instructional Design. The resource points out how
important it is to budget your project and consider the effort and cost that
will be going into the project. Just as project managers needs to remember to
set goals and objectives, having a budget is another form of a goal focusing on
keeping the project within range of resource use. Specific costs are listed
such as $28.00/hour for instructional designers and $10-$15 per professional
slideshow. The author of the site also listed estimates of duration or hours of
effort that would be expelled to create certain projects. For example, the
project that I am using for my course project is ELearning modules which would
take anywhere from 220 hours-750 hours depending on the level of interaction
that was required by the stakeholders. If the team worked 8 hours days, that’s
24-93 days of work! The site even has an Excel cost calculator which could
prove to be helpful in the future.
The
second resource that I evaluated was a slideshow presentation entitled How
Long Does it Take to Create Learning. This resource breaks down cost
and effort into categories depending on the type of learning that is desired.
Teacher led instruction would require the least effort whereas level three
elearning which would consist of online games and simulations would cost the
most and require the most effort. I was shocked to read that 1 hour of a level
3 elearning simulation would cost just over $50,000 to complete and 13% of the
effort devoted to the project would be instructional design. The
chart refers to the level 3 learning and the effort and cost associated.
Lastly, the site Time
to Develop One Hour of Training points out the difference between types
of training that is being developed as well. Kapp and Defelice point out that
all too many times the cost of projects is never estimated but only responded
to with an “it depends.” It is important however for clients and stakeholders
as well as the team members working on the project to see what they are up
against and have something to shoot for. This website also points out the
difference in cost from 2003-2009. As I would have expected, cost for most
everything has increased with years. Similar to the other sites, this provided
information that upheld that simulations or high levels of interactivity are
more expensive and time consuming. I appreciated this site however because it
points out some things that perhaps a project manager could do in order to
minimize the factors that go into the project such as clear communication,
conducting an orientation for stakeholders, etc.
Chapman Alliance. 2010. How Long Does It Take to Create Learning?
Retrieved from http://www.slideshare.net/bchapman_utah/how-long-does-it-take-to-create-learning
Clark, Don. 2010. Estimating Costs and Time in Instructional
Design. Retrieved from http://www.nwlink.com/~donclark/hrd/costs.html
Kapp, K., Defelice, R. 2013. Time to Develop One Hour of Training. ASTD. Retrieved from http://www.astd.org/Publications/Newsletters/Learning-Circuits/Learning-Circuits-Archives/2009/08/Time-to-Develop-One-Hour-of-Training
Meredith,
ReplyDeleteThese are great resources that provide guides for estimating the cost of many ID functions. While I am familiar with a few, I could only speculate on video production costs, programming, or what really consumes the majority of time and/or budget. Thanks for sharing!
Great resources! I particularly liked the Slideshare which provides some great estimates on resource cost for creating instruction. Particularly interesting is the breakdown by process or step. Thanks for sharing that!
ReplyDelete